What Have You Done (feat. Keith Caputo) – Unraveling the Tense Emotional Showdown


You can view the lyrics, alternate interprations and sheet music for Within Temptation's What Have You Done (feat. Keith Caputo) at Lyrics.org.
Article Contents:
  1. Music Video
  2. Lyrics
  3. Song Meaning
  4. A Vortex of Emotions: Love’s Tumultuous Symphony
  5. The Siren and The Haunting: Vocals that Cut Deep
  6. A Curse Unveiled: The Hidden Meaning Behind the Lyrics
  7. Memorable Lines: The Echoing Confessions of ‘What Have You Done’
  8. The Lyrical Journey: From Darkness to an Ambiguous Dawn

Lyrics

”Would you mind if I hurt you?
Understand that I need to
Wish that I had other choices
Than to harm the one I love”

What have you done now?

I know I’d better stop trying
You know that there’s no denying
I won’t show mercy on you now
I know I should stop believing
I know that there’s no retrieving
Its over now
What have you done?

What have you done now?

I, I’ve been waiting for someone like you
But now you are slipping away …oh (What have you done now!)
Why, why does fate make us suffer?
There’s a curse between us, between me and you

What have you done! What have you done!
What have you done! What have you done!
What have you done now?
What have you done! What have you done!
What have you done! What have you done!
What have you done now?

Would you mind if I killed you?
Would you mind if I tried to?
Cause you have turned into my worst enemy
You carry hate that I don’t feel
It’s over now
What have you done?

What have you done now!

I, I’ve been waiting for someone like you
But now you are slipping away …oh (What have you done now!)
Why, why does fate make us suffer?
There’s a curse between us, between me and you

What have you done! What have you done!
What have you done! What have you done!
What have you done now?
What have you done! What have you done!
What have you done! What have you done!
What have you done now?

I will not fall, won’t let it go
We will be free when it ends

I, I’ve been waiting for someone like you
But now you are slipping away …oh (What have you done now!)
Why, why does fate make us suffer?
There’s a curse between us, between me and
You. I’ve been waiting for someone like you
But now you are slipping away …oh (What have you done now!)
Why, why does fate make us suffer?
There’s a curse between us, between me and you

Full Lyrics

One might say that music is a canvas on which the myriad complexities of human emotion are painted in vibrant soundscapes. Within Temptation’s gripping track ‘What Have You Done,’ featuring the haunting vocals of Keith Caputo, does just that—plunging into the depths of strained human relationships and the consequential choices that follow their breakdown. The song touches on themes of love, betrayal, and the ensuing internal conflict. Its lyrics are a pulsating heart, throbbing with raw sentiment and the agony of difficult decisions.

At first blush, the track’s aggressive overtones may paint a picture of simple anger or disillusionment. But upon closer inspection, there lies an intricate narrative and emotional tapestry to be unwoven. Through the interplay of darkly melodious riffs and the poignant exchange of male and female vocals, the song presents a complex dialogue between two individuals caught in a toxic cycle, encompassing the duality of hurting and yearning.

A Vortex of Emotions: Love’s Tumultuous Symphony

The opening lines, a grim prelude to the unfolding drama, bring forth a disturbing proposition: one where harm is inflicted out of necessity, seemingly underlined by love. It’s a powerfully destructive notion—a stark contrast to the tender, nurturing aspects that love is often associated with. The phrase ‘What have you done now?’ serves as a haunting refrain; a rhetorical question that encapsulates shock, regret, and perhaps a sense of inevitability.

The dual nature of the poignant interrogatory sets the stage for a narrative that weaves through the entire song. On the one hand, it’s a direct address from one person to another, a confrontation with the consequences of their actions. However, on a deeper level, it feels like an introspective challenge, questioning the very nature of one’s decisions and emotions.

The Siren and The Haunting: Vocals that Cut Deep

Sharply contrasting with the serene qualities associated with Within Temptation’s traditional symphonic metal style, ‘What Have You Done’ introduces an almost percussive confrontation between Sharon den Adel and Keith Caputo. Sharon’s voice, often angelic and serene, clashes with Keith’s gravelly tone, creating an urgent and desperate narrative that grips the listener.

The dynamic interplay between the two characters represented by the vocalists draws the listener into the tumult of a toxic relationship. They animate the song’s discourse on the pain that partners may impose upon each other—pain that often emerges from the desire to maintain a bond that’s already fractured beyond repair.

A Curse Unveiled: The Hidden Meaning Behind the Lyrics

The chorus digs deeper into the state of helplessness felt by lovers caught in the tragic loop of a dying relationship. ‘Why does fate make us suffer?’ isn’t just a lament; it’s a profound inquiry into the seemingly predestined suffering that can manifest within human connections. The ‘curse between us’ could symbolically represent the intangible barriers that arise from misunderstandings, misaligned expectations, or perhaps deep-seated grudges.

This ‘curse’ is a testament to the scars that remain imprinted on a relationship long after the love seems to have faded. The sentiment reflects an age-old, almost mythological narrative, where fate plays a crucial role in human suffering, adding a layer of tragic inevitability to the song’s storyline.

Memorable Lines: The Echoing Confessions of ‘What Have You Done’

‘Would you mind if I killed you? Would you mind if I tried to?’ These lines are chilling in their candidness, breaking from the metaphorical to confront harsh possibilities head-on. It’s not simply about the end of emotional attachment; it’s frenetic, dark, and teetering on the edge of destruction. The lines resonate long after the music fades, leaving an indelible mark on the psyche of anyone who has felt the visceral sting of heartbreak-turning-to-hatred.

In stark contrast, ‘I will not fall, won’t let it go. We will be free when it ends,’ heralds a declaration of strength amid turmoil. It’s a vow of resilience and a nod to liberation that transcends the chaotic backdrop of the crumbling relationship that frames the song. These lines serve as the cathartic apex of the narrative, providing potential solace and the whisper of a fresh start beyond the pain.

The Lyrical Journey: From Darkness to an Ambiguous Dawn

As the song reaches its climax, the repetitions of ‘What have you done now?’ amplify the sense of urgency and exasperation, beating like a drum toward resolution or catastrophe. The repetition also serves as a poetic device, drilling into the consciousness of the listener the recurring cycles that define toxic relationships—the repeated mistakes, the ongoing pain, and the hope that one day the cycle will break.

In the end, ‘What Have You Done’ encapsulates the fear, the desperation, and the finality that come with the waning of love and the complexities of human relationships. It implores the audience to look beyond the superficial and to confront the emotions, consequences, and sometimes the monstrosity that can exist within what was once a sanctuary of affection and understanding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like...