“You Had Your Soul with You” by The National (Ft. Gail Ann Dorsey)

Different explanations have been offered as to the meaning of The National’s “You Had Your Soul with You”. One is that the track is actually optimistic and “bright”. However, a more-acceptable understanding is that the track is actually centered on a tumultuous relationship. And The National’s lead singer, Matt Berninger, plays the role of one of the lovers in this romance, with guest songstress Gail Ann Dorsey acting – albeit briefly – as the other. 

The reason for a lack of finality in deciphering this song’s ultimate meaning is due to the complexity of its lyrics. But based on comments made by Matt Berninger, such artistic ambiguity was likely the desired result when creating this song.

That said, there are still parts of “You Had Your Soul With You” which are easily understood. For instance, it is clear that this couple has already split, as they both note the earth-shattering heartbreak they personally experienced when the other had left. And the track overall seems to be focused on two primary sentiments expressed by Matt. First is a sense of disappointment that he feels in seeing the relationship dissolve. And second, somewhat ironically, seems to be a lack of appreciation for certain aspects of his partner’s personality.

Quick Facts about “You Had Your Soul with You”

• “You Had Your Soul with You” was released on March 5, 2019. It is the first single from the band’s eighth studio album titled I Am Easy to Find.
• This was The National’s first single to come out since they released “I’ll Still Destroy You” back in 2017.
• The song features guest vocals from the renowned American session musician Gail Ann Dorsey. Dorsey is best known for being a regular member of the band of the late English singer David Bowie.

Is this Gail Ann Dorsey’s first time of working with The National?

This track officially marks the first time that Dorsey has recorded a song with The National.

Who wrote “You Had Your Soul with You”?

According to Genius, the song was written by Aaron Dessner of The National and American singer and producer Doveman.